20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (2024)

Pin It

If you weren't already jonesin' for some holiday treats, this post will do the job! Tracey from The Kitchen is My Playground has 20 Christmas Treats for your Cookie Tray to show off today. This post is part of my Season of Serenity series, going on throughout the month of December! The photos alone make me want to ransack my pantry and bake up something delicious to devour...now. Keep reading for Tracey's fab recipes!

*************************

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (1)

Hello, everyone! I'm Tracey from The Kitchen is My Playground, and I'm honored to be sharing here at Serenity Now today. Thank you so much to Amanda for having me over!

The Christmas season is upon us. And one of my favorite parts of the Christmas season is holiday baking. With a blog name ofThe Kitchen is My Playground, there's probably no shocker there. Well, I've decided to focus today on Christmas cookie tray sweet treats! Oh, and I use the term 'cookie tray' very loosely, 'cause the Christmas day sweets certainly don't have to be limited to just cookies! Right?? Right.

We always have a cookie tray on Christmas day at my mother-in-law's house, and it's my job to keep it fully stocked. What about your family? Are you working on planning your family's cookie tray? If you are, then I've got 20 ideas for you right here!

Click on the item name link to see the recipe. Enjoy the virtual 'cookie' tray!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (2)

First up ...my absolute favorite Christmas sweet treat! My Mom has made these tasty little rum balls forEVER for Christmas. I honestly and truly can't remember a Christmas when we didn't have these.

Naturally, I have continued the tradition on...so we now end up with multiple batches throughout the holidays at both houses. But that's no problem for us! I've kicked 'em up a notch by using spiced rum and by ... well ... adding some extra splashes. Mmmmmm, they're good like that. But you may not want to light a match around 'em. I'm just sayin'.


20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (3)

2. Turtle Cookies
Or, insanely delicious Turtle Cookies, as they're titled in their blog post. This is by far the top readers' choice over at The Kitchen is My Playground - and might I just say ... the readers have fabulous taste.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (4)


3. Christmas White Chocolate-Dipped Pretzel Rods
Chocolate-dipped pretzels are always a hit. And with no baking involved, you can whip these beauties up pretty quickly. Use any type of Christmas-colored sprinkles you have on hand for embellishment. Dip ... sprinkle ... dip ... sprinkle ... it's as easy as that!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (5)

These may just be my new favorite chocolate chip cookie ... they're like gingerbread-meets-chocolate-chip-cookie, and it's a fabulous pairing. And guess what? ... these cookies are whole wheat. Shhhhhhh ... I won't tell if you won't.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (6)


5. 7 Layer Cookies
These 7 Layer Cookies are a Christmas tradition from my husband's family. Since marrying him, I've heard many stories about his Mom having to make more batches of these like the day or two before Christmas ... because somehow they had all disappeared before the big day.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (7)

How can you go wrong with chocolate graham crackers, praline topping, chocolate chips, pecans, and coconut? Ummmmm, in my humble opinion, you can't.


20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (8)


7. Classic Chocolate Fudge
Aaahhhhhhhh, Chocolate Fudge ... always a winner. Especially when it's super creamy like this one.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (9)

8. Candy Cane Cookies
The tradition of making these Candy Cane Cookies started way back when I was a kid. Mom and I made this batch Thanksgiving weekend last year to donate to a local women's shelter. Making them with Mom was a fun trip down memory lane!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (10)


9. Mocha Swirl Cookies
I made these beautiful swirls a couple of Christmases ago to include in the sweet treat boxes I give my co-workers as a gift. Were they a hit? Oh, yes!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (11)

10. Decadent Raspberry Truffle Brownies
Rich, dark chocolate brownies topped with a layer of creamy raspberry truffle filling. Oh, and then drizzled with more chocolate. Divine.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (12)


11. Pretzel Cookies with Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chips
Love, love, love the sweet-and-salty combination in these cookies! The pretzels and a tiny sprinkling of fleur de sel bring wonderful flavor for us salted chocolate lovers.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (13)

We all need a little dose of peppermint during the holidays! I'll take mine in chocolate chip cookie form, please.


20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (14)


13. Caramel-Walnut Squares
Cut these bars into small squares and place each square in a mini cupcake liner for a lovely presentation. These golden beauties are decadently delicious.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (15)

Want the taste of chocolate covered cherries in a cookie? Well, here you go!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (16)

Another one of my favorite Christmas traditions. I like mine 'naked' ... but add frosting and decorations, if you'd like!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (17)

Oh, these are soooooooo good! I'll just leave it at that. Okay?

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (18)

17. Raspberry-Almond Bars
Hmmmmmm, these oatmeal-based raspberry jam bars might just make an appearance on a Christmas breakfast treat tray, too. Oatmeal and jam make them count as a breakfast food, right?

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (19)

18. Cherry-Topped Brownie Bites
These little treats are so easy and so cute! Whip up a batch of brownies, cut them with a circle cookie or biscuit cutter, and top 'em with a cherry from a can of cherry pie filling. And, voila! ... pretty and festive little cherry-topped brownie bites.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (20)


19. Yuppy Chow {regular or Nutella versions}... or puppy chow ... or white trash ... or muddy buddies. Okay, this isn't even close to being a cookie ... but it's not Christmas at our house without a batch of this! It's my Dad's absolute favorite. So, hey, I say stick a bowl of it in the middle of the cookie tray and call it an extra good day.

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (21)

20. Christmas White Chocolate-Peppermint Popcorn
Don't want to stick a bowl of Yuppy Chow in the middle of your cookie tray? Okay. Then how about a bowl of White Chocolate-Peppermint Popcorn? You won't believe how amazingly yummy this stuff is.

I hope you've found a little 'cookie' tray inspiration from this tasty collection. Happy holiday baking from my kitchen {playground} to yours! Enjoy!!

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (22)

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (23)

Second grade teacher by day, kitchen adventurer by night and weekend. Follow along with Tracey's adventures on her blog The Kitchen is My Playground.
Google+ | Pinterest | Facebook | Twitter | bloglovin'

***********************

Drooling a little bit!

Which recipe looks tastiest to you?

*You'll find more holiday inspiration for this season at my Christmas series,A Season of Serenity, which is running all December long. The posts are rounded up as each one goes live. I'd love for you to visit!*

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (24)



If you enjoyed this post or found it helpful, I hope you'll click your "Pin It" button to add this post to Pinterest, or a +1 for Google+. And I always appreciate kind comments.


20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (25)

Pin It

20 Christmas Treat Recipes for Your Cookie Tray (2024)

FAQs

How many cookies should be on a cookie tray? ›

A great cookie plate should have at least three types of cookies. Or, for the ambitious baker, even more! Plan to include at least 3-5 cookies of each variety, so whoever gets to enjoy your creations can reach back for a second (or third!) of their favorites.

How many cookies do you need per person for Christmas? ›

A good rule to follow is for every guest to bake a half dozen cookies per each attendee. So, if 10 people attend, each guest would bring five dozen cookies to share. We've put together a chart to help you figure out just how many cookies to ask your guests to make.

What to put on a Christmas dessert platter? ›

Candies: Here are some sweet candy options: sugar cookie truffles, eggnog fudge, sugar cookie fudge, chocolate-covered pretzels, candied walnuts or pecans, candy canes, and Christmas M&M's (red and green). Cookies: Butter cookies, sugar cookies, and Christmas monster cookies made the cut for my board.

What can you put on a cookie tray? ›

Always include the classics. According to Bakeable member Peggy Daczewitz-Hamlin, every cookie platter needs to include the holiday cookies that everyone is craving. For Peggy, someone who's been baking cookie platters for 40 years, that's sugar cookies, almond crescents and chocolate-dipped butter cookies.

How to make the perfect cookie tray? ›

VARIETY IS THE SPICE:

Keep your tray visually interesting by varying the size, height, color and texture of your treats. Try stacking some of the cookies for visual interest or varying the size of the cookies, jumbo or mini's. Add some texture by having something soft and chewy along with something a little crunchy.

How many cookies should I order for 100 people? ›

When you have a solid idea of your RSVP count, we suggest 6 – 8 cookies per person. In other words, if you are expecting 100 guests, 100 x 6 is 600, divided by 12 is 50 dozen cookies. More than that is fine, but make sure you save your transport containers as you may be taking some home.

How long do you leave cookies on the tray after baking? ›

Remove cookies from the baking sheet as soon as they set. Most recipes tell you to leave them on for three to five minutes after taking them out of the oven. That time on the cookie sheet is still baking time because the sheet is hot.

What is a popular Christmas cookie shape? ›

There are staples, like a Christmas tree and a gingerbread man, but there are also cutters for those who don't celebrate Christmas, like the snowflake or the mitten.

How do you fill a Christmas cookie tin? ›

You'll want to fill the tin completely so that the cookies stay intact during transit. Line the bottom and the sides of your tin. You can use corrugated, tissue, or butcher block paper and top with pretty doilies. Separate each type of cookie with cupcake liners, shred, tissue, wax paper and/or parchment paper.

Do you decorate Christmas cookies before baking? ›

If you're making unfrosted cookies like shortbread or drop cookies, sprinkle the sugar on before baking. If you're icing the cookies, bake them, then decorate, and then shake the sugar on while the icing is still wet.

How much ahead of time can you make Christmas cookies? ›

You'll find that most of your favorite Christmas cookie recipes can be made anywhere from a month to six months before the 25th of December. (Consult this handy how-to guide to the matter.) Generally, most recipes will be best if baked and then frozen.

How many cookies do you need for 40 people? ›

How to Estimate the Number of Cookies Per Person? The general rule of thumb suggests calculating 2-3 cookies per person if other desserts are available. If cookies are the primary sweet treat, consider increasing the count to 4-6 per person.

How many cookies should I make per person? ›

Most recipes make somewhere from 24-48 cookies. But if you do the math on number of people and estimate 3-5 cookies per person, you'll be able to figure out if you need to double — or triple — your recipe.

What do you put on a baking tray? ›

There's a multitude of choices when it comes to greasing a baking pan. You can use anything from a canola oil or olive oil spray to coconut oil or butter. Olive oil can be used in a pinch, but is a little harder to get to stick to the sides of the pan if you go too heavy handed.

What do you put on an oven tray? ›

We recommend rice bran oil, though any cooking oil or fat with a high smoke point can be used for seasoning. You only want the lightest layer possible - wipe on, then wipe off.

What do you use baking trays for? ›

A sheet pan, also referred to as baking tray, baking sheet, or baking pan, is a flat, rectangular metal pan placed in an oven and used for baking pastries such as bread rolls, cookies, sheet cakes, Swiss rolls, and pizzas. A baker places a hot sheet pan full of bread rolls onto a cooling rack.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tuan Roob DDS

Last Updated:

Views: 6345

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (62 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tuan Roob DDS

Birthday: 1999-11-20

Address: Suite 592 642 Pfannerstill Island, South Keila, LA 74970-3076

Phone: +9617721773649

Job: Marketing Producer

Hobby: Skydiving, Flag Football, Knitting, Running, Lego building, Hunting, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Tuan Roob DDS, I am a friendly, good, energetic, faithful, fantastic, gentle, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.